top of page

Impact of management consulting on firms and the economy

Updated: May 22, 2023

Introduction

In the constantly changing world of business and economics, the role of management consulting cannot be exaggerated. With increasing global competition and rapid technological advancements, firms are faced with the constant pressure to innovate and improve. Many decide to get help from management consulting firms to navigate through these challenges, hoping to transform their businesses for better performance and higher growth. In this article we will explore the impact of management consulting on firms in the economy, talking about both the positive and negative sides of this strategic move.



Photo source - https://www.coursera.org/articles/what-is-management-consulting


The Upside: Driving Innovation and Change

One of the biggest contributions of management consulting to businesses is its remarkable potential to create innovation and cause change. Management consultants, with their diverse industry experience and objective perspective, are equipped to identify opportunities and solutions that in-house teams might overlook. They challenge the existing situation, ask difficult questions, and urge firms to venture beyond their traditional boundaries.

But not only do consultants identify opportunities, but they also offer strategic help on how to implement these changes. They provide invaluable expertise in a range of areas, including but not limited to project management, change management, strategic planning, and much more. By helping firms in changing their operational tactics and strategies, management consultants can directly influence their bottom line, leading to improved productivity and profitability of firms.

Beside strategic direction and advice, management consultants also play a pivotal role in transferring knowledge and skills. Working side-by-side with the in-house teams, consultants often offer training and development opportunities that significantly improve the internal capabilities of a firm. This benefit is particularly noteworthy in fast-paced industries, where maintaining a competitive edge is intimately tied to staying abreast of the latest technologies, practices, and market trends.



Photo source - https://vikingscareerstrategists.com/career-in-management-consulting-career-path-jobs-relevant-skills/


The Downside: Dependence, High Costs and Cultural Clash

Despite the many benefits of management consulting, it is not without potential drawbacks. One significant concern is the over-dependence on external advice, which could lead to an erosion of internal capabilities and decision-making autonomy. As firms depend more and more on consultants for strategic decisions and problem-solving, they risk devaluing their employees' insights, potentially damaging their morale and motivation.

What's more, hiring someone means that you will have to pay for them and in case of management consultants these costs are high. Especially small and medium firms which doesn't generate that much profit will experience a large opportunity cost in terms of money which could be spent on advertising or on buying more machinery, so firms should carefully consider whether they can higher potentially return on money spent on management consultants.

A further potential drawback of utilizing management consulting services is the risk of a cultural clash. Consultants often bring a different work ethic, business philosophy, or set of values, influenced by their varied experiences and best practices. This may conflict with the established culture of the firm, creating friction. Such conflicts can provoke resentment, lead to resistance against change, and cause disruptions in the workflow, impacting overall productivity.



Photo source - https://medium.com/thinking-pandas/the-struggle-is-real-how-to-make-it-as-a-struggling-entrepreneur-789059040690


The Balanced Approach: Maximizing the Benefits while Minimizing the Risks

Considering the potential advantages and challenges associated with management consulting, firms must strive to have a careful balance. This begins with establishing clear objectives and expectations for the consulting intervention, ensuring alignment with the broader strategic goals of the company. Companies should also strive to maintain open and transparent communication throughout the process, cultivating a collaborative environment that synergizes internal and external perspectives.

Simultaneously, firms must actively manage potential downsides. They must make coordinated efforts to protect internal capabilities by ensuring knowledge and skills are transferred from consultants to internal teams, and by encouraging employees to participate actively in the consulting process. They should also carefully manage the integration of consultants into the company culture and proactively address any potential conflicts or misunderstandings.



Photo source - https://www.freepik.com/vectors/balance-scale


Discussion and Conclusion

In conclusion, management consulting can offer significant benefits to firms, promoting innovation and driving change. It also has benefits for the economy as a whole, as it can drive economic growth by encouraging innovation, enhancing productivity, and creating jobs, which increase both Aggregate Supply and Demand in the economy. However, management consulting may not always be beneficial to firms and the economy. This is due to the reasons discussed in previous paragraphs, which suggest that it can potentially harm the firm and cause misallocation of resources in the economy, leading to decreases in short- and long-term supply. The damage caused to firms by management consulting could ironically increase the demand for these consulting services, thereby intensifying the situation. For example, this may be the case if firms become more dependent on consulting firms, indicating that more consulting services will be required in the future, and bringing more negatives, such as higher costs caused by increased demand for these services and. To avoid this unfavourable situation, firms need to adopt a balanced approach, which can be achieved by carefully managing the potential risks and challenges associated with using consulting services. This optimal use of management consulting lies not in full reliance or rejection, but in a strategic partnership that combines external expertise with internal capabilities and insights. So, in our modern dynamic economic landscape, such a balanced approach to management consulting will ensure that we get as much value as we can from management consulting in form of sustainable economics growth and success of the economy.


Photo source - https://www.azernews.az/region/119185.html


Sources - Harvard business review - consulting is more than giving and advice

Research gate - consultantce consequences

John Wiley - the management consultancy effect

University of Wisconsin whitewater - the role of management consulting


92 views4 comments

Recent Posts

See All

4 Comments


What a mervelous article! Cant wait to read more:)


Like

Виктор Ю
Виктор Ю
May 21, 2023

Informative and interesting. Great article ✅️

Like

Dmitriy D.
Dmitriy D.
May 21, 2023

From my experience. Often companies attract external consultants when a team cannot agree on some important issues, such as: strategies and organizational structure of the company, a matrix of responsibility, etc. A fresh side view can be useful in this case

Like
Kirill Derevytskyy
Kirill Derevytskyy
May 21, 2023
Replying to

Thank you for your comment. I totally agree with you that firms should seek external help from consultants when internal consensus on the mentioned issues cannot be reached, which is a very valid point which I unfortunately haven't mentioned. In such instances, the use of management consultants is justified, as organizational structure, the appropriate matrix, and other important issues such as technology implementation are vital to a company's proper operation and development. However, there are instances where external help from consultants may not be necessary. Therefore, before deciding to hire, firms should consider all factors carefully. Your experience enriches this discussion, and I appreciate your input.

Like
bottom of page